The Mermaid and Mrs. Hancock: Crisp, elegant, fascinating // Rave Book Review

“For mermaids are the most unnatural of creatures and their hearts are empty of love.”

My summary:

So all you have to know going into this book is that it’s set in the late 1700’s, and it revolves around Mr. Hancock, a lonely, widowed merchant who suddenly comes in possession of a mermaid, and that Angelica Neal is a prostitute (ahem, courtesan!) who comes to his attention. This book revolves around their lives and interactions.

***Genre: Historical fiction, magical realism

***Thank you to Edelweiss for sending an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions stated here are solely my own and have not been influenced in any way.


My thoughts: Wowee!

It is rare that a book with a lovely cover and an intriguing premise lives up to its packaging, yet not only was this book written so incredibly well, it also challenged me to think about what it was trying to say: for if I were to describe the moral of this story, there are almost too many intricacies for me to begin unraveling.

For one, the mermaid’s presence in this narrative is quite a fascinating tool. There are striking themes and dichotomies being set up between characters so that things are being said about freedom, self-fulfillment, and identity, and I walked away very contemplative in that regard: the author strikes key chords in relevant issues like marriage and self-autonomy, and I thought such themes were nicely tackled.

Furthermore, I enjoyed how easy this book was to follow. It reads like a classic in the fashion of Jane Eyre and Dorian Gray, and the prose was lyrical, intricate, and poetic, and it’s probably one of the most well-written books I’ve read in a while: it flowed easily enough for me to speed up whenever I needed some respite from the world-building, yet it offered just the right amount of craft for me admire at a more leisurely pace.

And the best thing is, the story feels familiar yet wholly unique! It addresses cerebral themes that are prevalent in historical fiction (i.e. women’s issues and struggles to conform to standards), but with the enigma of the mermaid’s significance hanging over these characters, there was a sense of omniscience and atmosphere permeating this narrative that prompted me to inhale-read this book in one sitting.

Bottom line, this book achieved the perfect balance between flowery writing and a clean-flowing story, and it engaged me from start to finish. There are a few unresolved threads that left me in want, but in the larger scheme of this narrative, this book is crisp, entertaining, and an absolute pleasure to read.

“We all must die one day. I ought not to leave the world just as I found it.”

Recommended? For whom?

Too often with beautifully crafted prose, books can become tedious, pretentious, and a bit of a pain to read, but this book flowed nicely despite its intricate writing. And although there are a few elusive morals that will leave you pensive at the end, the themes of the story will make themselves known to you along the way.

Therefore, if you love classics and historical fiction, I’d highly recommend this book! Certain parts of this story are very mature at times (sex and prostitution are huge players here, and there was be a case of rape) so I’d advise for ages 17 and up.

Bottom line: Lovely and satisfying!

This book is about finding a compromise between ambition and security. These characters are constantly yearning and gambling for things beyond their reach, and I liked the message about cherishing what you’ve already attained in your life.

So I’d give this book a near-five star rating! Again, there are a few storylines left unresolved and rushed developments that left me a tad skeptical, but this book was otherwise right up my alley: it was beautifully crafted yet mystifying and engaging to explore, and it’s probably one of my favorite standalones in recent years.

My rating: 4.5 to 5/5 stars


***By the way, apologies for my absence in the last few weeks. Not only have I been incredibly busy with family matters, I just didn’t feel like blogging for a while. No reason in particular, but the language portion of my brain did go into puberty mode for a while, so I got stuck. 😛 Likely will be back regularly next week, so until then.


  1. Every time I see a review for this book it is a raving review!

    I love how you describe the writing style, it sounds exactly how I felt about Wild Beauty – flowery and atmospheric but not so much that it becomes the focus over the story line. Plus I am always here for mermaid stories.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Am I weird because why is this the first time I’m hearing of this book? The cover looks familiar but I don’t think I’ve actually taken a proper interest to it until now, and I’m so happy that you enjoyed it because the little summary you have there sounds really good! (And also I haven’t read magical realism in AGES!) Great review, I’m definitely adding it to my TBR!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You totally should read it! I feel it’s underhyped due to the content being quite mature, but it’s very lovely and definitely one of the strongest standalones I’ve read in years. (Ahem and Madeline Miller recommended it, so that’s why I picked up in the first place haha) Thank you, and cheers! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

  3. !!!! I am so keen to try this book out!! I love it so much when there’s a bit of otherworldly-ness in older eras. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s a great description actually! This book feels more like historical fiction with just a dash of magical realism sprinkled on top, so I love the way you phrased that. 😉 Thank you!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. this book seems so amazing????? ” It read like a classic in the fashion of Jane Eyre and Dorian Gray”
    *rushes to sign up*
    skdlfjdslkjfsl THE PREMISE OH GOD
    also this review was amazing c:

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Seriously, your posts are a complete danger to my reading plans! There I was having my next few weeks all lined up (colour coded and all of that) and all I can think about now is how much I want to read this book. 🤪🙈

    Such a brilliantly put review, I loved it!

    “it also challenged me to think about what it was trying to say” is something I really appreciate. I love when a book challenges me and provokes me to think ways I haven’t thought about before. 👌😊

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hehe much obliged? I’m happy to wreck your schedule anytime! 😂😂

      And yes, this book left me scratching my head a bit, and I really liked that about it! I hope you enjoy, and thank you so much for the lovely comment as always Vera! ❤

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much!! The mermaid is more creepy than anything else, but I absolutely agree that it made the book more mysterious and intriguing. 😉 Hope you enjoy it!


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s